Volume:9, Issue: 1

May. 15, 2017

Pre-service ESL Teachers' Perceptions of COCA Use
Wang, Hao [about] , Summers, Robert [about]

KEYWORDS: corpus linguistics, pre-service ESL teachers, pedagogy

ABSTRACT: Scholars who research corpora and its pedagogical implications differ in their views; some believe that corpora should be integrated into teaching practices and teacher training programs, while others caution against such implementations and suggest that critical examinations of corpora use in classroom needs to be in place. To better understand the pedagogical implication of corpora, this study uses surveys and interviews to explore ten pre-service ESL teachers’ perception of using Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA) in ESL classrooms. The result suggests that COCA is beneficial for ESL teachers in designing classroom materials and developing digital literacy; however, our finding also indicates that learners’ L2 proficiency and logistics need to be taken into consideration when using COCA in classrooms.


With the emergence of new technologies such as emails, chat rooms, and World Wide Web and the turn for plurality and fluidity in language learning, both scholars and educators have realized the potential value of information communication technology (ICT) to develop language teachers’ multiliteracies competence, the ability to communicate with others via digital and online mediums (Cummins, 2000; Warschauer, 2000). Teaching with technology is likely to create an emancipatory learning environment in which individuals could use technology to obtain their authorship in the process of disseminating knowledge based on their own understandings and views (Lotherington & Jenson, 2011). Thus, scholars such as O'Keeffe and Farr (2003) note that technology needs to become integrated into teacher education programs so that future teachers can see the benefits of using technology tools in teaching and understand the importance of developing multiliteracies. In the current study, we thematically analyzed preservice ESL teachers’ perception of using COCA in classrooms, because we believe that understanding preservice teachers’ view of applying such technology in classrooms would provide more practical feedback to both corpus specialists and the English language teaching (ELT) profession. In the following sections, we will first review the concept of corpora, current debate regarding both sides of using corpora in ELT. Then, we will introduce the research context and participants and how the study was conceived and operationalized. Detailed analysis of our findings along with pedagogical implications will be discussed.

Definition of Corpora

As a pioneering corpora researcher, McKay published the first empirical study investigating teaching strategies of verbs using computer corpus in 1980. Based on his seminal work, various volumes and papers have devoted to conceiving Corpus Linguistics as a field and exploring its applicability to language teachers and learners (Boulton & Pérez-Paredes, 2014; Gries, 2009; Kennedy, 2014; McEnery, Xiao, & Tono, 2006;). As commonly defined, a corpus is a linguistic database that consists of “a collection of naturally occurring language text, chosen to characterize a state or variety of a language” (Sinclair, 1991, p. 171). Over the years, corpus specialists have created multimillion size corpora to facilitate language research and ELT, including but not limited to Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA, 450 million), British National Corpus (BNC, 100 million), and Michigan Corpus of Academic Spoken English (MICASE, 1.8 million). Two views regarding ELT using corpora have developed, and it is the discussions of these views to which we turn now.

For Corpora Use

From a teaching perspective, data from a computer corpus provides more useful information than dictionaries through concordance lines because teachers could use a corpus to examine the nuances between synonyms such as “big” versus “large” in different contexts (Tsui, 2005, p. 340); additionally, using corpus data helps teachers understand that language is usage-based and that prescriptive grammars could at times be inaccurate in explaining how language is used in daily communications (Tsui, 2005). Tsui’s findings align with other studies that explored the effectiveness of using corpora to teach English grammar and vocabulary through learners’ noticing of certain lexicogrammatical patterns embedded in concordance texts (Liu & Jiang, 2009) and the inductive and deductive learning opportunities created by using corpora in learning English language (Hunston, 2002; Sinclair, 2004). For instance, Liu and Jiang (2009) have observed that some benefits of using corpora in teaching include promoting learners’ awareness and discovery learning ability, enhancing learners’ understanding of lexicogrammatical rules and patterns, and developing an awareness of context. Similarly, Kaltenbock and Mehlmauer-Larcher (2005) indicate that computer corpora are of significant assistance in learning collocations and could help learners better understand semantic prosody of certain lexical items.

Against Corpora Use

Despite the preceding discussions of the benefits of using corpora in ELT, a few scholars have questioned its pedagogical application and believe that corpora represent externalized language data that has limited influence on language learners. For example, Prodromou (1997) argues that there needs to be more corpora to reflect the diversity of English language so that nonnative English speaking teachers could also be legitimately included in the TESOL profession. Widdowson (2000) claims that one acts as a third person observer in viewing the concordances in a corpus, which prevents one from having a direct experience with those concordance lines. Although research suggests that teachers are the ones who play a more crucial role on popularizing language teaching with corpora than corpora itself (Mukherjee, 2004). The above description centers on the discussion of corpora as not relatable to language learners and how language teachers may contribute to the appropriation of corpora for their own classrooms. Thus, the current study aims at understanding the pedagogical aspect of corpora use in ELT through examining ten U.S. pre-service ESL teachers’ perception of using COCA in classrooms.

Methodology

Context and Participants

Situated from a thematic analysis framework, the current study seeks to explore ten pre-service ESL teachers’ perceptions of using COCA in ESL classrooms. The participants are Master’s and PhD students majoring in TESOL, Secondary Education in ESL, and Applied Linguistics. As part of their assistantship package, the master students teach nonnative freshman composition classes. Among these participants, there are eight native English speakers and two non-native English speakers. Four participants had no prior experience with corpora in general and six of them had used COCA a few times. Pseudonyms were assigned to all participants to keep their confidentiality. Researcher Hao Wang is a native speaker of Chinese who is interested in using corpora to enhance ELLs’ language learning experience. Researcher Robert Summers is a teacher educator with rich experience in both foreign language and ESL classrooms at secondary and university level. He is interested in CALL and has conducted research based on Vygotskian framework.

Procedure

The nature of our research question determines that this study will be qualitatively oriented, using common inquiry methods including surveys, interviews, and field notes and In Vivo and thematic analysis as data analysis techniques (Reimer, 1996). The implementation of the multiple data collection methods and researchers’ field notes was conceived to improve the credibility of the study. In addition, we also went back to the participants after completing interview transcription so that further discussions on the research topic or any other relevant matters could be made.

In analyzing the data, In Vivo and thematic analysis are supplementary to each other as they both focus on distilling textual information from the data. In Vivo coding method refers to the process of extracting words and phrases from qualitative data and highlights individuals’ voices in coding (Saldaña, 2012). After initial coding, we conducted a second cycle of analysis by using thematic analysis to synthesize, classify, and conceptualize our previous findings. Thematic analysis is a commonly used data analysis method to encode qualitative information with the facilitation of themes, patterns, and models with themes (Braun & Clarke, 2006).

Before we used our surveys and interviews,, we chose to provide our participants with hands-on experience with using COCA to help them understand and  review its features. We conducted a sample lesson on English vocabulary learning with COCA to help familiarize the participants with the COCA website and its basic functions, during which  we demonstrated how to use COCA to search for collocates of particular words and pulled up register columns that indicate usage frequency of one word in five registers, namely spoken, fiction, magazine, newspaper, and academic. After our demonstration, the participants were asked to complete a vocabulary worksheet that asks them to find information regarding collocates of a word, how it is used in contexts, and the register where it has been most frequently used. After that we conducted an online survey, designed prior to the sample lesson, to collect the participants’ demographic information and their perceptions of COCA use in classrooms based on our delivery and their hands-on experience. Fifteen themes emerged from the survey responses that were then integrated into our interview questions and used in semi-structured interviews with our participants. After one researcher transcribed the interview recordings, the other one proofread the transcripts. We then used Merriam’s (1988) intensive analysis, developing categories and theory as our guidelines in thematizing our data. First, we read through the transcripts for several times to familiarize ourselves with the texts. This process of familiarization was critical as it enables researchers to discover patterns and topics. In what follows, we used markers to underline sentences and expressions that are relevant to our research topic.

Findings and Discussion

The first two survey questions are demographic in nature.  Figures 1 and 2 demonstrate the survey results for the first two questions with ten responding participants.

Figure 1. Participants’ responses to the survey question on their years of teaching

In total, 60% of the participants have had no more than 1 year of teaching experience, and another 40% of the participants’ teaching experience ranged from 2 to 4 years.

Figure 2. Participants’ responses to the survey question on their level of teaching

Based on the participants’ teaching level, Figure 2 shows the distribution, four participants were assigned K-12 ESL level, five were assigned university level, and one participant did not have any teaching load. 

Thus, most of the participants have had less than four-year teaching experience either in K-12 ESL or University adult ESL settings. Their comments on the remaining five questions were thematized.

Based on the interview results, eight categories were made: student resource, teacher resource, authentic language, access to technology, register, proficiency level, difficult to teach for communicative competence, and too much information. Examples from each category will be given in the following section.

Student resource. One of the features of Corpus Linguistics is its discovery learning, which allows students understand how native English speakers use certain language items thus promoting learner autonomy. In our data, some participants pointed out that students could refer to COCA when they encounter difficulties in English language learning.  Additionally, this allows for the development of digital literacy as students learn to answer their own questions through the use of technologically accessible corpora (in this case COCA). Lynn commented that when using COCA to search for unknown words, students are more likely to remember them:

I think when you figure things out for yourself instead of just getting an answer from a teacher you are a whole more likely to remember it and to do it correctly the next time, than just be given the answer every time and you never think about it or remember it.

Teacher resource. Corpus Linguistics has tremendously helped language teachers in designing syllabus, concordance-based materials and activities, tests, and feedback (Braun, 2005). From the comments we received, our participants think that COCA can serve as a teacher resource where they can pull information that will facilitate their lesson preparations; additionally, interactions with COCA are viewed as a rewarding experience for some preservice ESL teachers because they become more professionalized in such processes. In her response, Ashley suggested that in comparison with her native speaker instinct about certain English language usages, COCA is more reliable in answering students’ questions:

Sometimes when students ask me questions I don’t know the answer to, or they ask me what words are common with something, and I’m not sure, then I’ll tell them I’ll bring an answer tomorrow and I use corpus at home to really investigate.

Authentic language. The notion of authenticity is a double-sided sword. If one defines it according to native speaker standard, then it will confront with criticisms from scholars in pluralism and English as Lingua Franca (e.g. Tan, 2005), because such a definition endorses native speakerism that views language via a monolingualism lens and considers native speakers to be superior than nonnative speakers (Holliday, 2006). Thus, whether data from corpora are authentic or not should depend on one’s perspective of authentic language. The responses we garnered reflect authentic language in the sense that how the language is used by native English speakers and within real life contexts. For example, Emma recalled her previous teaching experience with COCA on transitions and suggested that texts from COCA were useful:

Because I wanted to provide the students with authentic examples of how people use these transitions so that they could see the variation and different type, so I pulled some of the common transition words, I pulled examples from COCA for that.

Access to technology. Our literature has indicated that the prominence of Corpus Linguistics is largely due to technological advancement, particularly the availability of computer labs in schools, because language learners would then have hands-on experience with using corpora and develop their abilities in discovering language patterns, comparing differences between registers, and digital technology in general. However, this might not necessarily be the case in practice as our interviewees suggested otherwise. Their main concern is access to technology. Despite the benefits that COCA may bring to ESL students and teachers alike, its demand for technology has caused problems in classrooms, particularly in peripheral countries. Erica, for example, mentioned that although COCA has great advantages in teaching English, many English language learners in China do not have access to technology.

Register. In linguistics, register refers to a variety of a language or level of usage, as determined by degree of formality and choice of vocabulary, pronunciation, and syntax, according to the communicative purpose, social context, and standing of the user (register, n.1.). Some of our interviewees reported that one of their most frequently used functions on COCA is register. As a student teacher, Emma commented that COCA is of great importance to academic writing class mainly because students can distinguish and understand differences:

… between what is slightly formal and appropriate for newspaper, and what is really, what you would use for super formal academic writing, so I think it’s really helpful to be able to compare those types of writing.

Proficiency level. Findings from interviews also indicate that language proficiency level may potentially play a role in students’ COCA use. Jessica, for example, mentioned that advanced learners may use COCA to refine their second language and become more independent in terms of language learning:

I think especially for … high level students … hopefully at that point, they are trying to be a little independent … I think at that level, they would probably be able to work the corpus themselves.

Difficult to teach for communicative competence. The notion of communicative competence was first put forth by Hymes (1971) to describe a person’s ability to use language in a social context. In language learning, this competence is one of a few variables that could influence an individual’s meaningful interaction with others in a foreign language (Savignon, 1972). Based on our interviews, most participants believe COCA does not play a major role in improving learners’ communicative competence. For example, Lynn mentioned that COCA can contribute to students’ awareness of communication in certain contexts but would not significantly improve their L2 communicative competence.

Too much information. The overwhelming number of language data provided by corpora allows learners and teachers to discover language patterns and understand the frequency differences underlying different patterns (Kennedy, 2014). However, in the responses from our participants, this gigantic data size can also pose problems. Some reported that COCA displays concordance lines that are just too overwhelming to students, particularly for students whose L2 proficiency is not well developed and have limited experience using COCA. John commented that the interface on COCA is not very user friendly, especially when the search involves using signs such as brackets and asterisks:

They have a lot of …. symbols and things like that doesn’t make it really user friendly, got be honest, interface is beyond searching for single words or something like that, it gets pretty complex, pretty quickly…

Drawing from the findings of the current research, using COCA in classrooms is a double-sided sword in that its seemingly exploits could be quickly turned into problems for teachers. On the former, our participants suggest that COCA can be a great learning tool for intermediate and advanced language learners who are more capable of understanding the contextual and linguistic information on COCA such as concordance lines. In addition, COCA serves a valuable role in vocabulary learning by providing information such as word frequency, register, and collocations. For example, in explaining the usage differences between say and articulate, the instructor could pull up two charts on the COCA and compare their usages based on the columns of different registers. Another feature of COCA that our participants discussed is its ability to develop learner autonomy and digital literacy. With the multimillion-word COCA, learners who have learned how to navigate COCA linguistically and logistically can use it as an English resource site to explore the language unbounded.  Such exploration also develops their digital literacy through interacting with computer technology.

On the other side, using COCA in classrooms is not without limitations. The most important factor to be considered is teachers’ attitudes towards using it. Two of the participants reported that secondary/elementary ESL English teachers rarely use technology in their classrooms. One of the reasons is because of the availability of technology in schools; another important reason is the lack of support from curriculum design. Using supplementary tools such as corpora is not within the school’s current agenda. Second, some instructors consider the massive amount of information on COCA to be problematic, because users need to acquire searching skills such as adding [ ]*, and other symbols when advanced search is in need. The next factor is students’ linguistic and sociocultural knowledge of the language. Without these support, certain lexical items and expressions would be incomprehensible to the students, thus lowering the overall effectiveness of using COCA.

Conclusions, Implications, and Directions for Further Research

Based on the current study, COCA shines in vocabulary instruction, enhancing learners’ awareness of sociolinguistic differences in L2, to some extent improving their communicative competence, and developing digital literacy. However, before implementing COCA, local contexts need to be taken into consideration, which involves teachers’ attitudes towards technology use in classrooms, computer accessibility, and learners’ L2 proficiency and knowledge of COCA. In order to harvest the benefits of COCA or any other corpora, teachers need to first understand that they are the ones who play a critical role in appropriating corpora as a valid teaching tool and developing students’ knowledge in using them. To that end, COCA needs to be integrated into pre-service teacher training programs so that student teachers could increase their familiarity with COCA and know how to effectively use it in classrooms. Additionally, teachers need to carefully select appropriate content from COCA so that students would not be overwhelmed by too many new words and expressions. It should also be noted that the participants in the current study comprised of eight Master students and two PhD students. Future research in this direction could further diversify the demographics of participants by recruiting both in-service and pre-service ESL teachers. While the COCA website itself as a tool could facilitate one’s language learning enormously, a number of other sociocultural and sociopolitical issues could limit its effectiveness, including access to technology, curriculum design, and students’ family background, thus research from different contexts is encouraged to enrich our understanding of the relationship between teachers’ perception of using computer corpora and English language teaching.


References

  1. Boulton, A., & Pérez-Paredes, P. (2014). Researching uses of corpora for language teaching and learning, ReCALL, 26(2), 121-127.
  2. Boyatzis, R. (1998). Transforming qualitative information: Thematic analysis and code development. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
  3. Braun, S. (2005). From pedagogically relevant corpora to authentic language learning contents. ReCALL, 17(1), 47-64.
  4. Braun, S. (2007). Integrating corpus work into secondary education: From data-driven learning to needs-driven corpora. ReCALL, 19(3), 307-328.
  5. Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
  6. Carter, R. (1998). Orders of reality: CANCODE, communication, and culture. ELT Journal, 52(1), 43-56.
  7. Carter, R., & McCarthy, M. (1995). Grammar and the spoken language. Applied Linguistics, 16(2), 141-58.
  8. Cook, G. (1998). The uses of reality: A reply to Ronald Carter. ELT Journal, 52(1), 57-63.
  9. Cummins, J. (2000). Academic language learning, transformative pedagogy, and information technology: Towards a critical balance. TESOL Quarterly, 34(3), 537-547.
  10. Granger, S. (2003). The international corpus of learner English: A new resource for foreign language learning and teaching and second language acquisition research. TESOL Quarterly, 37(3), 538-546.
  11. Gries, S. T. (2009). Quantitative corpus linguistics with R: A practical introduction. NY: New York: Routledge.
  12. Holliday, A. (2006). Native-speakerism. ELT Journal, 60(4), 385-387.
  13. Hunston, S. (2002). Corpora in applied linguistics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  14. Hymes, D. (1971). Competence and performance in linguistic theory. In R. Huxley & E. Ingram (Eds.), Language acquisition: Models and methods (pp. 1-5). London: Academic Press.
  15. Kaltenbock, G., & Mehlmauer-Larcher, B. (2005). Computer corpora and the language classroom: On the potential and limitations of computer corpora in language teaching. ReCALL, 17(1), 65-84.
  16. Kennedy, G. (2014). An introduction to corpus linguistics. NY: New York. Routledge.
  17. Lather, P. (2007). Validity, qualitative. In G. Ritzer (Ed.), The blackwell encyclopedia of sociology (pp. 5161-5165). Oxford: Blackwell Publisher.
  18. Lotherington, H., & Jenson, J. (2011). Teaching multimodal and digital literacy in L2 settings: New literacies, new basics, new pedagogies. Annual Review Of Applied Linguistics, 31,226-246.
  19. Merriam, S. B. (1988). Qualitative research and case study applications in education. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
  20. McCarthy, M., & Carter, R. (2001). Size isn’t everything: Spoken English, corpus, and the classroom. TESOL Quarterly, 35(2), 337-340.
  21. McKay, S. (1980) Teaching the syntactic, semantic and pragmatic dimensions of verbs. TESOL Quarterly, 14(1), 17-26.
  22. Mukherjee, J. (2004). Bridging the gap between applied corpus linguistics and the reality of English language teaching in Germany. In U. Connor & T. Upton (Eds.), Applied corpus linguistics: A multidimensional perspective (pp. 239-250). Amsterdam, New York: Rodopi.
  23. O'Keeffe, A. N. N. E., & Farr, F. (2003). Using language corpora in initial teacher education: Pedagogic issues and practical applications. TESOL Quarterly, 37(3), 389-418.
  24. Partington, A. (1998). Patterns and meanings. Using corpora for English language research and teaching. Amsterdam and Philadelphia: John Benjamins.
  25. Prodromou, L. (1997). Corpora: The real thing? English Teaching Professional, 5, 2-6.
  26. Reimer, B. (1996). Qualitative research and the post-positivist mind. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 130(3), 123-126. “register, n.1”. OED Online. June 2015. Oxford University Press. Accessed June 15, 2015. http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/161292?rskey=0L9p3R&result=1&isAdvanced=false
  27. Römer, U. (2004). A corpus-driven approach to modal auxiliaries and their didactics. In J. McH.
  28. Sinclair (Ed.) How to use corpora in language teaching (pp. 185-199). Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
  29. Saldaña, J. (2012). The coding manual for qualitative researchers. Washington, DC: Sage.
  30. Savignon, S. J. (1972). Communicative competence: an experiment in foreign language teaching. Philadelphia: Center for Curriculum Development.
  31. Sinclair, J. (1991). Corpus, concordance, collocation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  32. Sinclair, J. M. (2004). How to use corpora in language teaching. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
  33. Tan, M. (2005). Authentic language or language errors? lessons from a learner corpus. ELT Journal, 59(2), 126-134.
  34. Tony, M., Xioa, R., & Tono, Y. (2006). Corpus-based language studies an advanced resource book. NY, New York: Routledge.
  35. Tsui, A. M. (2005). ESL teachers' questions and corpus evidence. International Journal Of Corpus Linguistics, 10(3), 335-356.
  36. Warschauer, M. (2000). The changing global economy and the future of English teaching. TESOL Quarterly, 34(3), 511-535.
  37. Widdowson, H. G. (1991). The description and prescription of language. In Alatis J. (Ed.), Linguistics and language pedagogy: The state of the art (pp. 11-24). Georgetown: Georgetown University Press.
  38. Widdowson, H. G. (2000). On the limitations of linguistics applied. Applied Linguistics, 21(1), 3-25.
  39. Yoo, I. (2009). The English definite article: What ESL/EFL grammars say and what corpus finding show. Journal of English for Academic Purposes, 8(3), 267-278.




chenlina (Feb. 09, 2018)
chenlina20180210

canada goose jackets

jordan shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

doudoune canada goose

birkenstock shoes

adidas outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg boots

true religion jeans

mizuno running shoes

coach outlet online

ray ban sunglasses

jordan 4

pandora jewelry

supreme

nike air

polo ralph

pandora jewelry

adidas football boots

cheap nhl jerseys

cheap mlb jerseys

pandora charms

jordan 3

supra shoes

north face outlet

fingerlings monkey

coach factory outlet online

polo shirts

longchamp outlet

jordan

cheap nfl jerseys

polo ralph lauren

nfl jerseys

birkenstock sandals

nike uk

canada goose outlet

nike tennis

moncler uk

wholesale nfl jerseys

ralph lauren

ralph lauren

stussy hoodie

herve leger dresses

michael kors outlet online

ray ban

ugg outlet

manchester united jersey

wedding shoes

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet

adidas yeezy boost

coach

louboutin

flip-flops

flip flops

kate spade outlet

nike huarache

ugg boots

adidas wings

hermes

longchamp

oakley sunglasses cheap

air max

canada goose

ferragamo

harden vol 1

jordan shoes

mishka clothing

canada goose outlet

jordan 8

ray ban

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

jordans

converse

ugg boots

soccer jerseys

uggs outlet

kate spade outlet

kate spade

undefeated shoes

coach outlet online

michael kors outlet

nike free

van cleef & arpels jewelry

adidas slides

canada goose

coach handbags

ralph lauren

nike sb

baseball bats

nike free

air jordan

jordans

canada goose down jacket

air max 90

coach factory outlet

north face

moncler

jordan 1

coach outlet online

coach outlet online

prada

rolex replica watches

ralph lauren

blackhawks jersey

tommy hilfiger

ray ban

asics running shoes

ugg boots

ray ban sunglasses wholesale

asicsasics running shoes

burberry outlet

rayban

pandora jewelry

ralph lauren

flops

mcm bags

jordan

polo ralph

cheap jerseys

north face uk

ugg australia

valentino shoes

swarovski crystal

canada goose

canada goose outlet

miu miu shoes

baseball jerseys

north face uk

true religion

air max plus

ugg outlet

dior handbags

nike free

adidas flip flops

ugg boots on sale

converse shoes

doudoune canada goose

carnival shoes

mac cosmetics

ferragamo shoes

air max

cheap ray bans

pandora charms

nike dunks

nike lunarglide

timberland boots

manolo blahnik

ugg clearance

nike blazer shoes

polo outlet

nfl jerseys

tory burch

nike football boots

air jordan

christian louboutin

ugg

louboutin

air max

air jordan

ugg outlet

bvlgari rings

michael kors

michael kors handbags

pandora jewelry

yeezy shoes

cheap mlb jerseys

ugg boots

michael kors

nike blazer

ralph lauren uk

ugg boots

alexander mcqueen shoes

basketball shoes

ugg

tory burch outlet

prada

coach outlet online

cheap jordans

mont blanc

north face outlet

pandora jewelry

hermes outlet

louboutin

louboutin

air max 95

dolce and gabbana

stuart weitzman shoes

marc jacobs

adidas yeezy 350

ugg canada

curry shoes

ugg boots sale

hermes kelly bag

canada goose

juicy couture

jordan shoes

givenchy handbags

burberry outlet

nike roshe

nike outlet

nfl jerseys wholesale

adidas shoes

bcbg

nike outlet

ray bans

air max 270

ugg

adidas outlet

snapbacks wholesale

christian louboutin

supreme outlet

michael kors handbags

converse shoes

coach outlet online

true religion jeans

the north face

ugg boots

moncler outlet

air max 2017

canada goose outlet

air max 1

ugg outlet

nike mercurial superfly

michael kors

cheap rolex watches

canada goose jackets

uggs outlet

scarpe mbt

air max 2018

adidas uk

mlb jerseys

moncler

coach outlet

ray ban

nike free run

canada goose coats

lebron 15

north face jackets

nike presto

coach outlet

the north face

adidas stan smith

ugg boots

fitflops

moncler

jordans

burberry scarf

adidas superstar

nike cortez

oakley sunglasses

nike air max

vibram fivefingers

moncler jacken

mont blanc pens

supreme uk

moncler pas cher

michaelkors outlet

salvatore ferragamo

true religion jeans

louboutin

ugg

air max 97

swarovski

michael kors outlet

birkenstock outlet

timberland

jordan xx9

ralph lauren

north face outlet

uggs

oakley sunglasses

longchamp outlet

moncler outlet

coach outlet online

ugg outlet

moncler jackets

christian louboutin

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

nhl jerseys

ugg boots

canada goose canada

kate spade

kate spade outlet

louboutin

uggs outlet

ugg

clibin clibin (Jan. 26, 2018)
clb0127

cheap ray ban sunglasses

coach factorty outlet online

michael kors

adidas shoes

mbt

hermens

michael kors bags

ralph lauren

yeezy shoes

christian louboutin shoes

coach factory outlet online

ugg boots

coach outlet canada

uggs on sale

birkenstock shoes

fred perry polo shirts

ralph lauren sale

longchamp outlet

burberry outlet

pandora charms

michael kors outlet clearance

ralph lauren uk

coach outlet online

pandora jewelry outlet

ray bans

moncler outlet online

coach outlet online

cheap uggs

ralph lauren

kate spade outlet

moncler uk

louis vuitton outlet online

moncler coats

ugg boots

longchamp bags

coach outlet online

canada goose outlet online

nike sneakers

adidas outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet online

gucci outlet online

canada goose parka

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren uk

adidas outlet store

michael kors

canada goose

cheap oakley sunglasses

philipp plein

canada goose outlet store

kate spade outlet online

coach outlet online

hermes bags

cheap ugg boots

coach outlet store

ferragamo shoes

pandora charms sale clearance

nike air max 2018

bottes ugg

nmd adidas

mbt

ugg outlet

kate spade handbags

kate spade outlet online

ralph lauren outlet online

oakley sunglasses outlet

coach factory outlet

cheap air jordans

mlb jerseys cheap

uggs outlet

fitflop shoes

coach outlet canada

uggs outlet

air jordan shoes

gucci outlet

ugg

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

coach outlet store

pandora charms

burberry handbags

uggs outlet

ugg outlet online

ugg outlet

nike air max 97

canada goose coats

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet online

canada goose jackets

hermes handbags

coach outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

pandora charms sale

michael kors outlet store

red bottom

pandora charms outlet

pandora outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

the north face outlet

coach outlet online

salvatore ferragamo outlet

pandora sale clearance

ralph lauren outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

moncler uk

nike outlet

michael kors

michael kors outlet online

ugg canada

polo ralph lauren outlet online

canada goose jackets

cheap jordan shoes

ugg outlet online

jordans

coach factory outlet online

nike outlet store

ralph lauren sale

fitflop sandals

adidas nmd r1

adidas superstars

polo ralph lauren outlet online

pandora jewelry outlet

ugg boots

pandora charms outlet

louboutin outlet

polo outlet online

yeezy boost 350

uggs outlet

ralph lauren

christian louboutin sale

valentino outlet

pandora jewelry

fitflops sale

polo ralph lauren outlet

cheap jordans free shipping

uggs outlet

pandora charms outlet

air max

air jordan retro

ralph lauren outlet online

mbt shoes sale

ugg outlet store

cheap jordans for sale

michael kors outlet online

canada goose jackets

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

adidas campus shoes

cheap nfl jerseys wholesale

cheap jordans

michael kors handbags outlet

pandora jewelry

adidas nmd r1

air max

adidas ultra boost

nike air max 2018

polo ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren outlet online

coach outlet online

moncler outlet online

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

nike outlet online

michael kors outlet canada

ray ban sunglasses discount

burberry handbags

uggs

yeezy boost 350

mulberry outlet uk

canada goose outlet

timberland outlet store

ugg boots

canada goose

pandora jewelry store

oakley sunglasses outlet

kate spade outlet online

pandora uk

ugg boots outlet

ugg outlet store

pandora charms sale clearance

coach factory outlet online

burberry outlet online

the north face outlet

canada goose sale

north face jackets

pandora charms sale clearance

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses outlet

adidas yeezy boost 350

nike outlet store

fred perry shirts

timberland outlet

moncler

nike shoes

coach factory outlet online

ray ban sunglasses outlet

louis vuitton factory outlet

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet online

burberry outlet online

cheap ugg boots

the north face outlet

michael kors outlet online

ugg outlet online

adidas superstar shoes

ugg boots

coach factory outlet online

moncler jacket

michael kors bags

adidas yeezy boost

hermes bags

polo ralph lauren

mulberry uk

ugg boots

ugg boots

longchamp bags

ray ban sunglasses sale

ralph lauren uk

oakley sunglasses outlet

north face jackets

longchamp outlet store

cheap jordan shoes

ugg outlet

cheap nfl jerseys wholesale

coach outlet online

louboutin outlet

nike shoes

michael kors

birkin handbags

red bottoms

retro 11

pandora charms outlet

coach factory outlet online

cheap air jordans

mulberry

michael kors outlet store

louis vuitton outlet store

uggs outlet

coach factory outlet

pandora charms

canada goose outlet

nfl jerseys

michael kors outlet canada

michael kors outlet clearance

moncler sale

coach outlet store online

nike outlet store online

coach factory outlet

nike sneakers

coach outlet store online

michael kors outlet online

burberry handbags

pandora charms sale

cheap oakley sunglasses

ralph lauren

canada goose coats

fitflops sale

michael kors

oakley sunglasses for women

ray ban glasses

adidas

canada goose jackets

ugg boots

ugg sale

jordan shoes for sale

michael kors outlet online

kate spade handbags

canada goose sale

canada goose jackets

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet clearance

canada goose

the north face jackets

michael kors outlet store

salvatore ferragamo shoes

canada goose jackets

canada goose sale

adidas yeezy shoes

ugg outlet store

pandora jewelry

louboutin shoes

uggs clearance

cheap ray ban sunglasses

ralph lauren outlet online

michael kors outlet store

fitflops sale clearance

michael kors uk

michael kors outlet

uggs outlet

canada goose jackets

nfl jerseys

yeezy shoes

coach outlet store online

adidas outlet online

michael kors outlet store

kate spade handbags

mulberry handbags

coach outlet online

canada goose coats

timberland boots

adidas outlet store

moncler sale

canada goose coats

ugg boots

canada goose coats

adidas nmd runner

coach factory outlet online

adidas yeezy boost

nike zoom

coach outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet

north face outlet

pandora jewelry

coach outlet store

ugg outlet

moncler jackets

moncler coats

christian louboutin shoes

michael kors outlet store

cheap ugg boots

michael kors outlet store

ugg boots sale

cheap nike shoes

adidas store

moncler pas cher

canada goose jackets

moncler coats

ray ban sunglasses discount

polo ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

tory burch outlet online

canada goose coats

kate spade handbags

discount ray ban sunglasses

adidas yeezy

chenlina (Dec. 26, 2017)
chenlina20171227

ugg boots

michael kors outlet

giuseppe zanotti shoes

longchamp outlet

longchamp

pandora rings

north face uk

swarovski

nike outlet

ugg outlet

ugg boots

coach outlet online

air jordans

north face outlet

ugg

cheap uggs

birkenstock shoes

north face

supreme

blackhawks jersey

oakley sunglasses

moncler

pandora charms

scarpe hogan

manolo blahnik

adidas jeremy scott

mulberry

nike football boots

ugg clearance

ray ban outlet

uggs

ugg outlet store

michael kors outlet

true religion jeans

balance shoes

nike huarache

nike trainers

hollister co

ugg boots outlet

canada goose sale

canada goose outlet

birkenstock sandals

the north face

ray ban

polo ralph lauren

ugg boots

cheap nfl jerseys

ugg boots

tory burch outlet

canada goose

oakleys

michaelkors outlet

uggs outlet store

michael kors outlet online

ray ban sunglasses sale

pandora jewelry

coach outlet

ralph lauren

ralph lauren outlet

pandora jewelry

uggs outlet

jordan shoes

moncler outlet

canada goose jackets

uggs outlet

oakley vault

scarpe mbt

jordan shoes

uggs outlet

coach handbags

polo ralph

canada goose canada

canada goose outlet

flip flops

ugg outlet

air jordan

coach outlet online

tory burch outlet online

cheap mlb jerseys

ray ban sunglasses

rayban

ugg boots cheap

canada goose sale

nike huarache

canada goose

cheap nfl jerseys

nike tn

coach outlet online

kate spade outlet

ugg outlet

moncler outlet

uggs

burberry outlet

canada goose jackets

christian louboutin outlet

moncler uk

ralph lauren

ugg

north face outlet

polo ralph

ugg slippers

tory burch outlet

coach factory outlet

coach outlet

ferragamo shoes

ugg boots

nfl jerseys

burberry scarves

canada goose jackets

canada goose jackets

ugg pas cher

oakley sunglasses wholesale

ugg boots

coach outlet

coach outlet online

air max

cheap jordans

coach factory outlet online

ugg boots

pandora charms

nike factory outlet

canada goose

oakley sunglasses cheap

cheap mlb jerseys

michael kors outlet

juicy couture

polo ralph lauren

baseball jerseys

louboutin

canada goose jackets

ugg boots

flops

michael kors

cheap rolex watches

polo ralph lauren

jordan pas cher

ugg outlet

cheap ray bans

ralph lauren outlet online

supreme uk

ugg boots

coach

fitflops

moncler jacken

burberry outlet

hermes outlet

michael kors

ugg boots

coach outlet online

pandora jewelry

pandora jewelry

ugg outlet store

ralph lauren

flops

nike outlet

true religion jeans

michael kors taschen

ralph lauren outlet

coach outlet online

ralph lauren outlet

ugg boots

oakley sunglasses

nike jordans

timberland

canada goose jackets

michael kors outlet

moncler

doudoune canada goose

ugg boots

louboutin

adidas yeezy boost

coach

ugg outlet

nike blazer shoes

ferragamo

louboutin

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

moncler jackets

ugg boots

coach factory outlet

ugg outlet

michael kors handbags

ugg boots

cheap nfl jerseys

ugg boots

nike outlet

ugg outlet store

tommy hilfiger

christian louboutin outlet

burberry outlet

canada goose outlet

nike free run

ray ban

uggs outlet

longchamp outlet

north face

christian louboutin

nike air max

oakley sunglasses

true religion jeans

jordans

uggs outlet

air max

coach outlet

michael kors

coach outlet online

coach factory outlet

moncler outlet

coach factory outlet

oakley sunglasses

adidas uk

tory burch uk

hermes

nfl jerseys wholesale

oakley sunglasses cheap

polo ralph lauren

kate spade

ugg boots

prada handbags

ray bans

burberry outlet canada

north face outlet

north face uk

jordan shoes

polo shirts

canada goose outlet

supreme

mont blanc

coach outlet

ugg boots

nhl jerseys

burberry scarf

michael kors outlet

prada

ugg boots

the north face

moncler outlet

canada goose jackets

under armour outlet

hermes birkin

prada

pandora jewelry

timberland boots

ugg boots

adidas wings

ugg boots

jordan retro

moncler

birkenstock outlet

michael kors outlet online

canada goose jackets

nba jerseys

oakley sunglasses

pandora charms

michael kors handbags

jordan shoes

cheap nhl jerseys

canada goose outlet

burberry outlet online

mont blanc pens

basketball shoes

air max

jordan shoes

rolex replica watches

moncler jackets

ugg boots

ugg canada

jordans

timberland boots

converse shoes

polo ralph lauren

canada goose outlet

the north face

mont blanc

christian louboutin

coach outlet

the north face

moncler uk

prada bags

moncler

true religion

flip flops

supra shoes

20171226caihuali (Dec. 25, 2017)

ferragamo outlet

true religion jeans

polo outlet

michael kors outlet

ugg outlet

air max 90

michael kors

longchamp bags

moncler jackets

uggs outlet

michael kors handbags

moncler outlet

cheap jerseys

adidas wings

coach handbags

mulberry handbags

valentino outlet

ugg outlet

ugg boots clearance

adidas nmd

fitflops shoes

michael kors handbags

chrome hearts outlet

polo ralph lauren

michael kors handbags

fitflops outlet

michael kors outlet

nike outlet

ugg outlet

ralph lauren polo

coach factory outlet

jordan shoes

true religion outlet

pandora outlet

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet

ugg outlets

ray bans

tory burch outlet

air max 1

nike store

mulberry handbags

ugg boots clearance

ugg boots

coach outlet

coach factory outlet

michael kors wallets

polo outlet

bottega veneta outlet

burberry outlet

cartier outlet

kate spade outlet

ugg outlet

michael kors outlet

longchamp outlet

oakley sunglasses

ray ban sunglasses

coach outlet

ralph lauren uk

coach outlet

canada goose outlet

nfl jerseys

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin shoes

swarovski outlet

ugg outlet

yeezy boost 350

new balance shoes

air max 90

jordan shoes

moncler jackets

cheap nfl jerseys

ferragamo shoes

polo ralph lauren

cazal sunglasses

coach factory outlet

ugg boots clearance

true religion uk

cheap nhl jerseys

michael kors outlet

ralph lauren polo

canada goose outlet

ferragamo outlet

true religion outlet

canada goose jackets

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet

canada goose outlet

Girls shoes

nike shoes

fitflops sale clearance

oakley sunglasses

pandora charms sale clearance

coach outlet online

ralph lauren polo shirts

nike sko

jordan shoes

longchamp pas cher

oakley sunglasses wholesale

cheap jerseys

prada outlet

christian louboutin outlet

michael kors outlet

nike shoes

coach outlet

cheap snapbacks

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

canada goose jackets

burberry outlet

christian louboutin online

ugg outlet

nike roshe one

canada goose outlet

tory burch outlet

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors handbags

coach factory outlet

kate spade outlet

coach outlet

ugg boots

michael kors outlet

chrome hearts

mont blanc pens

nfl jersey wholesale

canada goose outlet

tods outlet

ralph lauren polo shirts

cheap mlb jerseys

true religion jeans

michael kors outlet

polo ralph lauren

ugg outlet

ralph lauren outlet

ugg black friday

fred perry polo shirts

longchamp handbags

air max uk

puma outlet

oakley sunglasses

ugg cyber monday

longchamp pliage

uggs outlet

pandora charms

hermes outlet

vans greece

true religion jeans

oakley sunglasses

ugg outlet

coach outlet online

hermes outlet

true religion jeans

pandora charms

polo ralph lauren

pandora jewelry

giuseppe zanotti outlet

pandora charms

moncler outlet

nike outlet

kobe bryant shoes

swarovski crystal

ray ban sunglasses

nike air max 2015

michael kors outlet

denver broncos jerseys

nike free 5

lebron james shoes

asics shoes

michael kors outlet online

ecco sale

nike air force 1

oakley sunglasses

nike trainers

coach outlet

nba jerseys

nike blazer pas cher

ecco shoes

ralph lauren pas cher

coach outlet

supreme clothing

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors

football shirts

oakley sunglasses

christian louboutin uk

pandora outlet

coach outlet

cheap nfl jerseys

michael kors handbags

lacoste soldes

christian louboutin shoes

nike shoes

polo outlet

christian louboutin outlet

supra shoes

tory burch outlet

cheap jordans

polo shirts

burberry outlet

coach outlet

huaraches shopping

longchamp handbags

longchamp solde

canada goose outlet

tory burch outlet

true religion jeans

mulberry handbags

pandora charms

michael kors outlet online

pandora outlet

canada goose jackets

michael kors

moncler outlet

canada goose cyber monday

herve leger outlet

vans sko

canada goose black friday

nike shoes

oakley sunglasses

uggs outlet

coach outlet

pandora jewelry

ysl outlet

nike trainers

coach outlet online

adidas shoes

canada goose outlet

rayban sunglasses

ralph lauren polo

mulberry sale

polo outlet

lakers jerseys

christian louboutin outlet

ugg boots clearance

canada goose outlet

ray ban sunglasses

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

coach outlet online

ferragamo outlet

tory burch outlet

nike foamposite

dansko shoes

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

prada shoes

ralph lauren outlet

mbt shoes

ugg outlet

ugg outlet

yeezy boost

christian louboutin outlet

nhl jerseys

pandora jewelry

uggs outlet

tory burch shoes

polo ralph lauren

michael kors outlet

uggs outlet

20171226caihuali

gnd (Dec. 17, 2017)
Monitoring replica watches uk Laboratory - To replica watches observe the effect of metal and other materials in the fake watches uk processing technology, and strive to swiss replica watches uk continuously improve.
klinik (Dec. 13, 2017)
http://klinik-acing.com Cytotec merupakan salah satu merek obat aborsi yang diperdagangkan oleh Misoprostol dan di produksi oleh Pfizer, peredaran obat aborsi merek CYTOTEC sudah di setujui oleh FDA sehingga obat aborsi cytotec ini sangat aman untuk anda gunakan untuk menggugurkan kandungan. daftar kota besar yang menjual obat aborsi jual obat aborsi bali jual obat aborsi semarang jual obat aborsi surabaya jual obat aborsi malang jual obat aborsi bekasi jual obat aborsi bandung jual obat aborsi batam jual obat aborsi tangerang
UKEssay Papers (Nov. 28, 2017)
I loved the post, keep posting interesting posts. I will be a regular reader… Essay Writing Service
UKEssay Papers (Nov. 28, 2017)
I loved the post, keep posting interesting posts. I will be a regular reader… Essay Writing Service

Home | Copyright © 2018, Russian-American Education Forum